Skip to content
FAST SHIPPING: Orders placed as "priority" or "expedited" will ship from our facilities within ONE business day!
FAST SHIPPING: Orders placed as "priority" or "expedited" will ship from our facilities within ONE business day!

Valentine Peanut Butter Cookie Recipe

This recipe is an amazingly TASTY recipe! If you love Valentine's Day and you love Peanut Butter cookies, then you hit the jackpot with this Valentine's Peanut Butter cookie recipe!

We used peanut butter in place of the butter in this take on a traditional cookie recipe, which turned out super nutty and soft & most importantly, delicious! Great for children too, they can get involved and decorate the Valentine's Day Peanut Butter cookies with frosting, edible glitter & dusts, sprinkles and some of their own creativity!

valentine, valentines day, valentine baking, valentine's day ideas, valentine's day date, valentine's day recipe

TOOLS & INGREDIENTS

valentine, valentines day, valentine baking, valentine's day ideas, valentine's day date, valentine's day recipe

Prep: 30 min. + chilling Bake: 10 min./batch + coolingMakes about 4-1/2 dozen

INSTRUCTIONS:

  • In a large bowl, cream peanut butter and sugars until light and fluffy, about 4 minutes.Beat in the eggs, milk and vanilla. Combine the flour, baking powder and baking soda;add to the creamed mixture and mix well. Cover and refrigerate for 2 hours or until easyto handle.
  • On a lightly floured surface, roll out dough to 1/4-in. thickness. Cut with 2-in. to 4-in.using Bakell Heart Shaped cookie cutters. Place 2 in. apart on un-greased baking sheets.
valentine, valentines day, valentine baking, valentine's day ideas, valentine's day date, valentine's day recipe
  • Bake at 375° for 7-9 minutes or until edges are browned. Cool for 1 minute before removing from pans to wire racks to cool completely. Paint & frost cookies with edible Luster Dust and decorate with Valentine's Day Tinker Dust colors to add that final sparkle!
  • Now, what do we think about this? Remember, if you'd like to mix it up or have a peanutallergy, swap it out with some almond butter!

From Bakell to you, Happy Valentines Day!

This recipe is an amazingly TASTY recipe! If you love Valentine's Day and you love Peanut Butter cookies, then you hit the jackpot with this Valentine's Peanut Butter cookie recipe!

We used peanut butter in place of the butter in this take on a traditional cookie recipe, which turned out super nutty and soft & most importantly, delicious! Great for children too, they can get involved and decorate the Valentine's Day Peanut Butter cookies with frosting, edible glitter & dusts, sprinkles and some of their own creativity!

TOOLS & INGREDIENTS

valentine, valentines day, valentine baking, valentine's day ideas, valentine's day date, valentine's day recipe
valentine, valentines day, valentine baking, valentine's day ideas, valentine's day date, valentine's day recipe

Prep: 30 min. + chilling Bake: 10 min./batch + coolingMakes about 4-1/2 dozen

INSTRUCTIONS:

  • In a large bowl, cream peanut butter and sugars until light and fluffy, about 4 minutes.Beat in the eggs, milk and vanilla. Combine the flour, baking powder and baking soda;add to the creamed mixture and mix well. Cover and refrigerate for 2 hours or until easyto handle.
  • On a lightly floured surface, roll out dough to 1/4-in. thickness. Cut with 2-in. to 4-in.using Bakell Heart Shaped cookie cutters. Place 2 in. apart on un-greased baking sheets.
  • Bake at 375° for 7-9 minutes or until edges are browned. Cool for 1 minute before removing from pans to wire racks to cool completely. Paint & frost cookies with edible Luster Dust and decorate with Valentine's Day Tinker Dust colors to add that final sparkle!
  • Now, what do we think about this? Remember, if you'd like to mix it up or have a peanutallergy, swap it out with some almond butter!
valentine, valentines day, valentine baking, valentine's day ideas, valentine's day date, valentine's day recipe

From Bakell to you, Happy Valentines Day!

Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Edible Shimmer Flakes_Pack-Bakell

Valentine's Day Collection Edible Shimmer Flakes Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)

$19.99
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Tinker Dust_Pack-Bakell

Valentine's Day Collection Edible Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)

$24.99
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)-Dazzler Dust_Pack-Bakell

Valentine's Day Collection Decorative Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4 PC Set)

$24.99
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)-Brew Glitter_Pack-Bakell

Valentine's Day Collection Edible Beverage Glitter Heart Gift Pack (4PC Set)

$24.99
Valentine's Day Cupcake making Edible Topper Gift Set
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Cupcake making Edible Topper Gift Set
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell

Valentine's Day Collection Cupcake Making Kit (4PC SET)

$19.98
Edible Food Grade Glitter and Metal Cookie Cutter Valentine's Day Gift Set
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Edible Food Grade Glitter and Metal Cookie Cutter Valentine's Day Gift Set
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell

Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit A (3PC SET)

$14.99
Valentine's Day Edible Paint Heart Cookie Cutter and Cake Stencil Value Gift Set
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Edible Paint Heart Cookie Cutter and Cake Stencil Value Gift Set
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell

Valentine's Day Collection Cookie Making Kit B (4PC SET)

$18.99
Valentine's Day Purple Edible Glitter and Heart Cake Stencil Value Gift Set
Valentine's Day Collection Stencil Decoration Combo Pack A (2PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Stencil Decoration Combo Pack A (2PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Stencil Decoration Combo Pack A (2PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Stencil Decoration Combo Pack A (2PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Purple Edible Glitter and Heart Cake Stencil Value Gift Set
Valentine's Day Collection Stencil Decoration Combo Pack A (2PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Stencil Decoration Combo Pack A (2PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Stencil Decoration Combo Pack A (2PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell
Valentine's Day Collection Stencil Decoration Combo Pack A (2PC SET)-Valentine's Day_Gift Set-Bakell

Valentine's Day Collection Stencil Decoration Combo Pack A (2PC SET)

$11.99

Inspirational Stories From Around The World - We are Bakell

We want to hear from you #bakell - Follow us on Instagram @bakell_baking & like us on Facebook